No announcement yet.

New stem cell technique -- no embryos used

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    New stem cell technique -- no embryos used

    New stem cell technique -- no embryos used

    Published Yesterday | Stem Cells , December 2006 | Unrated

    Only women could be treated with unfertilized egg method
    Scientists have found a way to make stem cells from unfertilized eggs, suggesting a potential alternative to controversial and technically difficult embryo cloning.

    A group at Harvard University led by research fellow Kitai Kim and stem cell pioneer George Daley, an adviser to the California Prop. 71 stem cell program, reported success Thursday with the new method using mouse eggs. Similar experiments with human eggs are under way.

    The goal is to make stem cells from a particular patient -- or stem cells that carry a particular set of genes -- in order to make pancreatic cells to treat diabetics or neurons to treat people with incurable brain disorders. Cloning, or somatic cell nuclear transfer, may be one way to do this, but the new method appears to be easier.

    Deriving stem cells from unfertilized eggs without cloning offers "another way to generate cells that might be suitable for transplantation," Daley said during an interview.

    "It's a very efficient process," he said, adding that although it hasn't been achieved yet in humans, "there is no theoretical reason" the mouse experiments can't be duplicated using unfertilized human eggs.

    Results were described Thursday in the online edition of the journal Science in mostly dry technical language. But the experiments also put a new twist on some of the central ethics questions confronting regenerative medicine, such as what qualifies as an "embryo" and whether cloning is even necessary.

    The new stem cell recipe mimics the early steps in a type of reproduction common in some species of invertebrates, fish and reptiles. Known as parthenogenesis, a term derived from the Greek for "virgin birth," it allows females to produce offspring without need of a male to fertilize the egg.

    Parthenogenesis is considered virtually impossible for mammals, although laboratory attempts have been made. Now, it seems it might be a strategy for high-tech medical repairs.

    One catch: It would work only for the half of the population that produces eggs.

    "It's only good for women," said Arlene Chu, director of scientific activity at the Prop. 71 stem cell agency, known as the California Institute for Regenerative Medicine.

    Scientists are trying to produce stem cell lines from the cellular precursors of sperm, but that's more technically challenging than using eggs, which are larger and biologically more stable. So there's no immediate prospect of a male counterpart to the female-only stem lines described in the latest study.

    This raises the prospect -- still science fiction -- that a hospital might be able to treat a woman's spinal cord injury by extracting her eggs and turning them into stem cells, which then might be made into neurons or other cells for injection at the injury site. A man with the identical injury would be out of luck.